Link to forum list in sig?

UKSBD

Moderator
  • Dec 30, 2005
    13,058
    1
    2,842
    Would it be appropriate to add a link to a list of business forums in my sig?
    Would the mods, administrators have any objections to this?
     
    Its ok because Dave @ Mytchmac promotes the sales and markting forum in his sig too. whether its 1 or 5 shouldnt matter. Nothing in the rules says you cannot mention other forum url's either.

    ps as long as its not the banned one :)
     
    Upvote 0
    Its ok because Dave @ Mytchmac promotes the sales and markting forum in his sig too. whether its 1 or 5 shouldnt matter. Nothing in the rules says you cannot mention other forum url's either.

    ps as long as its not the banned one :)
    What is the banned one you speak of? I saw the rumpus thread and I'm curious.

    I gather it's being censored so could you email me on contact @ openmindedsolutions.co.uk ?
     
    Upvote 0
    well you will see a lot of familiar faces there :)

    sure I will email anyone who wants the link.
     
    Upvote 0
    A while ago a group of people joined this forum and were just PMing people with the link to 4notworking. So the easiest thing to do was add it to the swear filter so the link didn't get through.

    As you can see from other posts, there's no problem at all with linking to other forums. But blatantly posting/PMing/Joining just to promote another forum is obviously not cricket.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: sabian1982
    Upvote 0
    ok that makes sense I suppose. So that should not prevent us from mentioning the name then?

    As there's loads of other forums out there and a list is even being compiled by ukbdf, we should be able to include it where it is not being used in the wrong sense?
     
    Upvote 0
    You'd need to contact Sift about that. I have no control over the filters.

    My personal opinion is that Brett who runs 4N appeared to be encouraging it at the time, so he's just shot himself in the foot really.
     
    Upvote 0
    I really dont see it as a comparison site though. Both are different to me, so I dont see any issue with regards encouraging members to visit or register there. I use various forums each for what meets my purpose. I imagine it's the same for most people.
     
    Upvote 0
    No disrespect intended Duane.
    But do the moderators have the authority to answer questions like the one
    I originally asked, or should I wait until an administrator answers the question?
     
    Upvote 0
    A while ago a group of people joined this forum and were just PMing people with the link to 4notworking. So the easiest thing to do was add it to the swear filter so the link didn't get through.

    As you can see from other posts, there's no problem at all with linking to other forums. But blatantly posting/PMing/Joining just to promote another forum is obviously not cricket.

    Mr Jackson

    You forgot the other reason which I posted about on another thread.

    The fact that certain members of that forum (in full agreement with the forum leader) took it upon themselves to launch a full scale tirade of this forum because of one member who had asked to be banned from here.
    That one member has been back on this forum in a number of guises since and once threatened two of the moderators.

    Those members of that network had never been on here before but joined solely for the purpose of causing trouble.

    The Pm ing of members took place just after that incident.

    So now you have the history (but the full history would take far too long).

    It terms of offerings Michael as you are now fully aware that network has a completely different business model to this one and therefore cannot even be considered as a competitor.

    They are aimed at very different requirements.....some people like social networking others don't:D
     
    Upvote 0
    Hi,

    No problem linking to other forums in your sig...but as Duane said, if it gets to the point where someone's using UKBF to actively drum up members for another forum, it's a different matter!

    Cheers,
    Darren
     
    • Like
    Reactions: UKSBD
    Upvote 0
    Can I ask why you feel the need to have this list of 10 other business forums in your signature?

    Nowt to do with me, merely curious...... Is there something 'in it' for you?
     
    Upvote 0
    Nothing in it for me at all, I have had the list there for over 18 months.

    In a thread earlier this week someone asked about other forums so I posted
    a link to my list, others then said it would be better if it provided more info;
    member numbers, post numbers, threads etc.

    I updated the list and added the further info after people mentioned it,
    and will include it in my sig for the next week so anyone interested can
    see it.
     
    Upvote 0
    They are aimed at very different requirements.....some people like social networking others don't:D

    Totally agree they are very different animals, I'm a member of both and they seem to meet different needs (although I've absolutely no interest in the "history" as it does not concern me).

    Interesting comment about social networking, not sure I understood what you mean insomuch as to some level all online communities are social and networking to varying degrees?
     
    Upvote 0
    Nothing in it for me at all, I have had the list there for over 18 months.

    In a thread earlier this week someone asked about other forums so I posted
    a link to my list, others then said it would be better if it provided more info;
    member numbers, post numbers, threads etc.

    I updated the list and added the further info after people mentioned it,
    and will include it in my sig for the next week so anyone interested can
    see it.

    No probs, curiosity got the better of me :)
     
    Upvote 0
    (although I've absolutely no interest in the "history" as it does not concern me).
    But the comment was aimed at someone who asked so this comment coming from you isn't at all neccessary is it Ray;):D

    Interesting comment about social networking, not sure I understood what you mean insomuch as to some level all online communities are social and networking to varying degrees?
    Take a poll among the memebers here to and ask if they wish to attend regular network events (eg BRE, BNI or 4 N) and you will find a majority that say they are not interested........one of the reasons that they are on these forums anyway(Or at least they did last time the question was asked).

    Yes there is a degree of social interaction but not the primary reason most people are on here.:)
     
    Upvote 0
    so this comment coming from you isn't at all neccessary is it Ray;):D

    It was entirely necessary, as the history had already been laid out (which had nothing to do with the thread ahem), so if I was going to comment on this thread it was entirely appropriate that I give full disclosure - I'm a member of both and would not criticise one or the other or vice versa.

    Take a poll among the memebers here to and ask if they wish to attend regular network events (eg BRE, BNI or 4 N) and you will find a majority that say they are not interested........one of the reasons that they are on these forums anyway(Or at least they did last time the question was asked).
    As a subject that fascinates me, has there been such a survey? I'd love to have a look at what people want

    Yes there is a degree of social interaction but not the primary reason most people are on here.:)
    Hence my interest in any surveys, or is this a personal opinion? It will be fascinating to see how this forum develops based on market research and policy implementation by Sift. I know Darren is working really hard on this area and I look forward to whatever is rolled out accordingly.
     
    Upvote 0
    It was entirely necessary, as the history had already been laid out (which had nothing to do with the thread ahem)

    Ah but the thread was taken off topic long before someone asked the specific question and therefore got a specific answer. (And the OP hasn't asked for the thread to be returned to the OT have they?):D:D
     
    Upvote 0
    It's a bit too niche and too small to go on the main list, but I will create a
    list of niche forums too, not with quite so much info though.

    What would best describe it?
    legal forum, Investigators forum, PI forum or something else?

    You could have course set up a number of sub lists to show specific interest forums rather than the more general ones:)
     
    Upvote 0
    Ah but the thread was taken off topic long before someone asked the specific question and therefore got a specific answer. (And the OP hasn't asked for the thread to be returned to the OT have they?):D:D

    So you didn't have to pull me up for saying:

    But the comment was aimed at someone who asked so this comment coming from you isn't at all neccessary is it Ray

    Which suggests I was taking it off topic or making irrelevant comments, especially after your post, which had nothing to do with the OP:

    You forgot the other reason which I posted about on another thread.

    The fact that certain members of that forum (in full agreement with the forum leader) took it upon themselves to launch a full scale tirade of this forum because of one member who had asked to be banned from here.
    That one member has been back on this forum in a number of guises since and once threatened two of the moderators.

    Those members of that network had never been on here before but joined solely for the purpose of causing trouble.

    The Pm ing of members took place just after that incident.

    So now you have the history (but the full history would take far too long).

    It terms of offerings Michael as you are now fully aware that network has a completely different business model to this one and therefore cannot even be considered as a competitor.

    They are aimed at very different requirements.....some people like social networking others don't:D
     
    Upvote 0
    You could have course set up a number of sub lists to show specific interest forums rather than the more general ones:)

    Working on it ;)
    Don't want to just have a list of forums for the sake of it though.
     
    Upvote 0
    Which suggests I was taking it off topic or making irrelevant comments, especially after your post, which had nothing to do with the OP:
    Taking off topic......................no

    Irrelevant..................definitely even in the context of your own post. Therefore the only reason to state it is to make a subtle attack on what I had said........ i.e. what I had stated was irrelevant even though it directly answered a question.
     
    Upvote 0
    Taking off topic......................no

    Irrelevant..................definitely even in the context of your own post. Therefore the only reason to state it is to make a subtle attack on what I had said........ i.e. what I had stated was irrelevant even though it directly answered a question.

    And my post simply mentioned full disclosure, given what had been said previously in the thread.

    Your observation that I was making a "subtle attack" on you is totally ridiculous. I'm speechless....
     
    Upvote 0

    Latest Articles