Advice request: irregularities at work during probation

Mirror

Free Member
Sep 27, 2018
15
1
Good afternoon. I am writing to inquire as to what can be done regarding a situation that is affecting a relative at work.

She started a new job 2 months ago, and immediately had problems with management. Here are the issues:

1) She is in training, but she was deliberately classed as a full time employee by her manager - thus, she was missing all the targets and wasn't being paid for training hours. She discovered that after the first six weeks, when there was a conflict with her manager and HR had to become involved.

2) She's NEVER been told that there are any performance issues during her bi-weekly assessments, even though she has been deliberately accused of making serious mistakes several times by the department manager + supervisor, but only verbally. The accusations have been so egregious that her colleagues have had to leap to her defense; to put an example, she was accused of mishandling confidential documents that another colleague had approved and sent for processing. Even though there is an audit trail proving this, as all changes have to be confirmed and approved by the handling employee and a supervisor, her manager kept accusing her of causing a data breach. This was, until the employee who had processed those documents presented the audit trail to this manager, proving that the accusations were false.

3) Things escalated the day when my relative arrived at work, logged in and discovered that all the cases that had been assigned to her, had been deleted. Each employee account can only be accessed by the employee him/herself, and their supervisor + manager. So, only the supervisor or manager could have deleted my relative's cases. When she asked for help, the manager exploded into a rage and accused of being incompetent and deleting important data from the database. When my relative explained that the audit trail shows who has entered each account, and therefore this could prove her innocence, the manager accused her of being hysterical and trying to victimize herself to divert attention from her mistakes.

This prompted my relative to talk to her union representative, who in turn spoke with HR. HR made an investigation and sent a warning to the manager and supervisor involved. This is when it was discovered that my relative had been classed as a full time employee even though she is a trainee, and hadn't been paid for her training hours.

Since then, things have escalated. The manager and supervisor are extremely hostile to my relative, and have spread rumours about her, which had effectively isolated her and caused fellow employees to shun her. Also, they withhold information from her and do not provide her with support of any kind - this is so blatant that other employees have actually had to tell managers that they should share relevant issues with her.

Today, she has been told that from next Monday, she will start her training again from scratch and won't be allowed to work on any cases, because she is a disaster. When my relative has asked which targets she is missing or what incidences could justify this decision, the manager has said that there are no standards or targets to be missed, because her decision is based on 'my careful observation of your performance'. That can mean anything, so my relative has requested formal feedback about her performance, listing her mistakes (there is also an audit trail for these). At this point the manager has dismissed her and said that my relative will be supervised from someone else from now on, and she doesn't have any obligation to give any further explanation to her.

Now, the training that my relative will have to start has NOTHING to do with her job. She has been required to enrol on courses on diversity, harassment, inclusion and conflict management, which will take the entirety of her work hours and won't provide any insights on the job itself, which she has been doing without any problems until now. Also, she doesn't understand why she has to take these courses when she is the one who is being bullied.

She has spoken with her union rep again, who has apologized to her for giving her bad advice, as she is on probation and technically, she can be dismissed at any point. He claims that there is very little that can be done, if anything at all. We're going to consult a lawyer, but I wanted to ask for everyone's insights.

Thank you for reading my message and sorry for taking so much space. I'd also like to apologize for the convoluted explanation, as I am a bit upset.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lisa Thomas
Good afternoon. I am writing to inquire as to what can be done regarding a situation that is affecting a relative at work.

She started a new job 2 months ago, and immediately had problems with management. Here are the issues:

1) She is in training, but she was deliberately classed as a full time employee by her manager - thus, she was missing all the targets and wasn't being paid for training hours. She discovered that after the first six weeks, when there was a conflict with her manager and HR had to become involved.

2) She's NEVER been told that there are any performance issues during her bi-weekly assessments, even though she has been deliberately accused of making serious mistakes several times by the department manager + supervisor, but only verbally. The accusations have been so egregious that her colleagues have had to leap to her defense; to put an example, she was accused of mishandling confidential documents that another colleague had approved and sent for processing. Even though there is an audit trail proving this, as all changes have to be confirmed and approved by the handling employee and a supervisor, her manager kept accusing her of causing a data breach. This was, until the employee who had processed those documents presented the audit trail to this manager, proving that the accusations were false.

3) Things escalated the day when my relative arrived at work, logged in and discovered that all the cases that had been assigned to her, had been deleted. Each employee account can only be accessed by the employee him/herself, and their supervisor + manager. So, only the supervisor or manager could have deleted my relative's cases. When she asked for help, the manager exploded into a rage and accused of being incompetent and deleting important data from the database. When my relative explained that the audit trail shows who has entered each account, and therefore this could prove her innocence, the manager accused her of being hysterical and trying to victimize herself to divert attention from her mistakes.

This prompted my relative to talk to her union representative, who in turn spoke with HR. HR made an investigation and sent a warning to the manager and supervisor involved. This is when it was discovered that my relative had been classed as a full time employee even though she is a trainee, and hadn't been paid for her training hours.

Since then, things have escalated. The manager and supervisor are extremely hostile to my relative, and have spread rumours about her, which had effectively isolated her and caused fellow employees to shun her. Also, they withhold information from her and do not provide her with support of any kind - this is so blatant that other employees have actually had to tell managers that they should share relevant issues with her.

Today, she has been told that from next Monday, she will start her training again from scratch and won't be allowed to work on any cases, because she is a disaster. When my relative has asked which targets she is missing or what incidences could justify this decision, the manager has said that there are no standards or targets to be missed, because her decision is based on 'my careful observation of your performance'. That can mean anything, so my relative has requested formal feedback about her performance, listing her mistakes (there is also an audit trail for these). At this point the manager has dismissed her and said that my relative will be supervised from someone else from now on, and she doesn't have any obligation to give any further explanation to her.

Now, the training that my relative will have to start has NOTHING to do with her job. She has been required to enrol on courses on diversity, harassment, inclusion and conflict management, which will take the entirety of her work hours and won't provide any insights on the job itself, which she has been doing without any problems until now. Also, she doesn't understand why she has to take these courses when she is the one who is being bullied.

She has spoken with her union rep again, who has apologized to her for giving her bad advice, as she is on probation and technically, she can be dismissed at any point. He claims that there is very little that can be done, if anything at all. We're going to consult a lawyer, but I wanted to ask for everyone's insights.

Thank you for reading my message and sorry for taking so much space. I'd also like to apologize for the convoluted explanation, as I am a bit upset.
The union rep has, finally given her the right advice.
 
  • Like
  • Wow
Reactions: eteb3 and Mirror
Upvote 0
The union rep has, finally given her the right advice.
Thanks. I guess that our hands are pretty much tied, then. ? I will consult a lawyer nonetheless, to see how we can avoid further escalation... I will also tell my relative to start looking for another job, which I guess is the only real solution. It's a pity, because she does like the job itself but alas, I guess that nothing can be done.
 
Upvote 0
It appears she has real problems.

It might not be what you wish to hear, but she probably should start looking for a new job. It’s not right, but unless her boss is promoted, demoted or sacked, I doubt things will change.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mirror
Upvote 0
It appears she has real problems.

It might not be what you wish to hear, but she probably should start looking for a new job. It’s not right, but unless her boss is promoted, demoted or sacked, I doubt things will change.
I understand. It's something very difficult to accept, but I guess that some battles just cannot be won. Thank you very much for your help :)
 
Upvote 0
Even if the person has been bullied and harrassed? Or is that separate to any dismissal?
Unless it can be proved that the behaviour was due to a protected characteristic. that's it.
 
Upvote 0
Unless it can be proved that the behaviour was due to a protected characteristic. that's it.
My relative is partially deaf and this has been used against her in some interactions (as in, 'you're misunderstanding what I'm saying/doing because you can't hear properly'). Thank you for pointing this out.
 
Upvote 0
Good afternoon. I am writing to inquire as to what can be done regarding a situation that is affecting a relative at work.

She started a new job 2 months ago, and immediately had problems with management. Here are the issues:

1) She is in training, but she was deliberately classed as a full time employee by her manager - thus, she was missing all the targets and wasn't being paid for training hours. She discovered that after the first six weeks, when there was a conflict with her manager and HR had to become involved.

Do other employers not count full time employees taken on as full time employees from when they start work?
 
Upvote 0
My relative is partially deaf and this has been used against her in some interactions (as in, 'you're misunderstanding what I'm saying/doing because you can't hear properly'). Thank you for pointing this out.

There are reasonable adjustments that employers can make.
Can be as simple as a few quid on equipment or arranging meetings in such a way as to reduce background noise.
Or more complex - the point being has to be useful for the person.

Not always possible to make adjustments on everything.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Mirror
Upvote 0
Do other employers not count full time employees taken on as full time employees from when they start work?
Thanks for your reply. Employees who are in training are treated differently, as training has to be paid separately for some reason. That is why she was being underpaid.

Thanks for letting me know about the disability adjustments. :)
 
Upvote 0

Latest Articles