Hedgehogtoys is a lovely url which is a great start.
However I really think that you should hand this over to someone with a handle on usability and an eye for design. Or at least get someone to give you the right over all colours. I do know that choosing colours is incredibly hard but some people just have the knack of it. (Not me though)
With the greatest repect for your efforts it really looks homemade at the moment. The text is so dodgy looking that I can't even read the address at the top properly.
Watch out for that lefthand menu. It is already getting too long to be usable.
Your story should be on an 'About Us' page and the home page should be turned over to products which is what your visitors will be looking for.
The scrolling text is a bad idea for many reasons too boring to repeat here.
It's nice that the site resizes to fit the screen. Makes it feel like it was made especially for me.
At the moment you have no help, no Frequently Asked Questions, No returns policy, no terms and conditions, but I expect these are on your to do list.
I could say some other stuff but I think your main problem is getting the unified look and feel of the site right, keeping in mind the important issue of usablilty. A good looking site will certainly make you more sales and that's the bottom line. It will repay you to get some help with this.