Europe should we stay in or get out?

Newchodge

Moderator
  • Business Listing
    Nov 8, 2012
    22,633
    8
    7,948
    Newcastle
    • Like
    Reactions: simon field
    Upvote 0
    Have you traveled on an AVE train in Spain? Makes Network Rail look sick doesn't it?

    Guess we look at things from a different viewpoint, I was mainly thinking of the whole generation of youths condemed to 35-50% unemployment levels, with many Greeks now earning the equivalent of £100 a week.

    The EU is failing many of it's citizens, and many who are told they are better off in reality are simply more in debt.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: ShirleyM
    Upvote 0
    D

    Deleted member 226268

    Guess we look at things from a different viewpoint, I was mainly thinking of the whole generation of youths condemed to 35-50% unemployment levels, with many Greeks now earning the equivalent of £100 a week.

    The EU is failing many of it's citizens, and many who are told they are better off in reality are simply more in debt.


    ........ with many Greeks now earning the equivalent of £100 a week.


    Those must be the few who actually get paid ......

    http://www.keeptalkinggreece.com/2016/07/20/1-2million-greeks-await-3-15-months-for-their-salaries/

    I expect Italy is rapidly crumbling down into the same situation.

    Mass rising unemployment for everyone throughout Europe, + waves of sponging immigrants
    imposed on their environment, the native peoples are becoming very annoyed.


    European countries are drowning in debt, using more debt to get themselves out of debt,
    until next time.

    Where are the positive answers and solutions from all those highly paid useless people
    who call themselves Economists.

    There are going to be some serious riots soon.


    http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/france-and-italy-next-economic-crash-europe-a7054801.html


    .
     
    • Like
    Reactions: ShirleyM
    Upvote 0
    D

    Deleted member 59730

    Why will we not export goods to Spain and Italy? We're not part of the USA political and economical 'club' either, but we export plenty of stuff there.
    Because you voted not too. You voted to no longer be part of the EEC which means we will no longer part of the club. Just how many US made cars do you see on UK roads?

    The paymasters of UKIP even said that mass unemployment was a price worth paying for freedom.
     
    Upvote 0
    You don't need to be part of the club to export to the EU. So many people think being part of the Single Market is the only way a country can sell goods to the EU, but that is incorrect. Many countries export to the EU, without being in the EU, the EEC, or EFTA.

    What has US made cars to do with it? We are discussing exports, not imports. There will be no mass unemployment if we leave the EU, but I'm quite certain that will happen if free movement of people continues at this rate, or higher.
     
    Upvote 0

    KM-Tiger

    Free Member
    Aug 10, 2003
    10,346
    1
    2,893
    Bexley, Kent
    • Like
    Reactions: ShirleyM
    Upvote 0
    If you still believe liars Boris and Farage just wait a couple of years.

    Do you believe we cannot sell to EU countries unless we are in the EU, EEA, or EFTA? You certainly imply it, going by the above comment.

    If so, please explain how other countries, eg. China, who are not in the EU, EEA, or EFTA, manage to export to EU countries, and even without a trade agreement.

    We will be able to sell to the EU, without being a member of the EU, EEA or EFTA, and we will be better off financially (and politically) by being outside of those customs unions.
     
    Upvote 0

    Cobby

    Free Member
    Oct 28, 2009
    4,079
    857
    I thought you wanted to play 'pantomime'
    Oh, I did! :) I was using it to show how your ineffective your argument was.

    If so, please explain how other countries, eg. China, who are not in the EU, EEA, or EFTA, manage to export to EU countries, and even without a trade agreement.
    We're still a member of the EU so of course we don't have a trade agreement. Do you even understand what you are arguing half the time?

    and we will be better off financially (and politically) by being outside of those customs unions.
    No we won't. ;)
     
    Upvote 0

    Cobby

    Free Member
    Oct 28, 2009
    4,079
    857
    Boring. There was a good article in The Times (a pro-remain paper btw) telling you remain-refuseniks to get over it. I recommend you take a peek ;)
    We've put up with a decade of whiney, ill-informed racists and tiny-minded nationalists complaining about the EU - you guys didn't get over it, why would you expect your opposition to? It seems the only kind of democracy you like is when you get your own way. ;)

    Just because the vote is over doesn't mean you can't go on making the argument, and the Remain supporters have a very strong argument and a very valid grievance over the execution of the referendum itself.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: Paul Norman
    Upvote 0
    We're still a member of the EU so of course we don't have a trade agreement. Do you even understand what you are arguing half the time?

    Well it is perfectly clear that you do not understand how trade works.

    Trade agreements are not required in order to trade with any country. We, and the EU, trade with the USA (for example) and neither the UK or the EU has a trade agreement with the USA. If the EU refuses to trade with us after we leave, they will be in breach of international law.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: quikshop
    Upvote 0

    Cobby

    Free Member
    Oct 28, 2009
    4,079
    857
    Well it is perfectly clear that you do not understand how trade works.

    Trade agreements are not required in order to trade with any country. We, and the EU, trade with the USA (for example) and neither the UK or the EU has a trade agreement with the USA. If the EU refuses to trade with us after we leave, they will be in breach of international law.
    I was pointing out that we can't have a trade agreement as you describe, while still in the EU; we negotiate collectively with greater leverage and our membership conditions include not running side negotiations for trade deals. I mention it because you seem mildly confused over their nature and application.

    Obviously we can trade outside of those conditions but it's more expensive for businesses to do so.
     
    Upvote 0

    quikshop

    Free Member
    Oct 11, 2006
    3,644
    714
    54
    Wolves
    We've put up with a decade of whiney, ill-informed racists and tiny-minded nationalists complaining about the EU - you guys didn't get over it, why would you expect your opposition to? It seems the only kind of democracy you like is when you get your own way.

    Don't flatter yourself claiming to be my opposition; you don't qualify as worthy of the debate. I am pro-Europe and an internationalist. The current quasi-communist EU project however is not pro-Anglo Saxon so my vote was for Brexit, knowing full well that we'll get another chance in the years to come to return to the EU fold.

    Your mask of faux intellect and reason has slipped good and proper there Cobby. I won't hold my breath waiting for your apology for what you clearly implied.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: simon field
    Upvote 0

    Toby Willows

    Free Member
    Jun 20, 2016
    761
    167
    We've put up with a decade of whiney, ill-informed racists and tiny-minded nationalists complaining about the EU - you guys didn't get over it, why would you expect your opposition to? It seems the only kind of democracy you like is when you get your own way. ;)

    Just because the vote is over doesn't mean you can't go on making the argument, and the Remain supporters have a very strong argument and a very valid grievance over the execution of the referendum itself.

    Personally I've not had a vote go my way many times, from general elections, by elections, board room votes and what were having tea on Friday. Each and every time I've accepted the outcome and got on with life. I certainly wouldn't be still complaing about it over a month later, that has no productive value at all.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: ShirleyM
    Upvote 0

    WebFixer

    Free Member
    Jul 14, 2012
    50
    15
    London
    RE: EU accounts. (I wonder if a small business was audited the way the EU is, how long could it last, with current local oversight?)

    Anyhoo, I spent 10 mins searching and I post 3 links. They're a long read, but the gist I got is that, yea, the accounts are signed off. Sort of. If you change the norm on what counts as 'signing off'.

    I liked this quote, as a good example of caustic invective, which I try to practice in my daily life:

    "Over the past twenty five years, I have delivered hundreds of training courses in PR and Journalism to thousands of PR people and journalists. I’ve also written four books on PR and propaganda, one of which theSunday Timeswas kind enough to name as its Business Book of the Week. A key element of my workshops is to caution delegates against the temptation to try to use PR methods dishonestly to influence people. I illustrate this using the most egregious press releases sent to me over the years as examples.

    In future I shall not use my collection of ‘black’ press releases. I shall instead use the press handout from the EU Court of Auditors (below) as my primary training example as it is the worst that has ever crossed my desk. In my opinion, It has everything that a press statement should not have: dissembling, deceit, weasel words, misdirection, a fog of undefined terms, arrogant condescension, and a personal attack on journalists reporting accurately and honestly. It is a clarification that it wholly lacking in clarity.

    It says the EU’s accounts have been signed off but at the same time says that part of the EU’s accounts has not been signed off. It places the blame for failure to comprehend this elementary distinction on us, the public. If we think the accounts haven’t been signed off, it’s all been a “misunderstanding” on our part because we don’t understand EU accounting procedures.

    Or, as George Orwell (who must be spinning at near light speed in his grave) would have said, we have not yet learned, like the EU, to practice the art of Doublethink."

    http://www.richardmilton.net/have-the-eu-accounts-been-signed-off-or-not/


    https://fullfact.org/europe/did-auditors-sign-eu-budget/
    http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-eu-referendum-36276175
     
    Upvote 0

    Cobby

    Free Member
    Oct 28, 2009
    4,079
    857
    Don't flatter yourself claiming to be my opposition; you don't qualify as worthy of the debate. I am pro-Europe and an internationalist. The current quasi-communist EU project however is not pro-Anglo Saxon so my vote was for Brexit, knowing full well that we'll get another chance in the years to come to return to the EU fold.

    Your mask of faux intellect and reason has slipped good and proper there Cobby.
    "I'm smarter than you". What marvellous debating skills. I sure am unworthy of that.

    I won't hold my breath waiting for your apology for what you clearly implied.
    Please accept my apologies if you inferred anything I didn't imply.
     
    Upvote 0

    Cobby

    Free Member
    Oct 28, 2009
    4,079
    857
    Personally I've not had a vote go my way many times, from general elections, by elections, board room votes and what were having tea on Friday. Each and every time I've accepted the outcome and got on with life. I certainly wouldn't be still complaing about it over a month later, that has no productive value at all.
    Of course it has productive value, don't be so ridiculous. From the legal possibility of our exit being halted, down to just keeping the facts of the arguments in the forefront of the public consciousness.

    So when you've voted in a general election and your party has lost, you never make another political argument or comment of any kind until the next election? I don't believe you.

    Political engagement and discussion continues. That's what comes of a politically engaged people. Leave supporters can keep framing it as "complaining" or "whining" or whatever but all they are doing is disrespecting the political and democratic right of half the nation to keep making their argument. All it does is make the Leave supporters seem small-minded and petty, concerned only with the *fact* that they won and not *what* they think they won.
     
    Upvote 0

    Newchodge

    Moderator
  • Business Listing
    Nov 8, 2012
    22,633
    8
    7,948
    Newcastle
    That's pretty offensive, but par for the course with you. I know enough to know when you're telling porkies!

    Accusing a fellow member of telling lies is pretty offensive, but par for the course with you.
     
    Upvote 0

    Newchodge

    Moderator
  • Business Listing
    Nov 8, 2012
    22,633
    8
    7,948
    Newcastle
    And we still don;t know whether Shirley knows anything about the subject or whether she just repeats what Farage and Boris say.

    Actually, I think we can make a pretty reasonable deduction.
     
    Upvote 0

    Latest Articles