Ali, the original question hasn't been ignored, this whole thread is about what constitutes a "going rate" for an SEO consultant which is worth their fee. And yes, with affiliate websites I obviously know that conversions are important. Not quite sure what your point is there...
I wouldn't say it's free promotion for you either. You may be getting results, but you aren't the only person in the world who could do it using that method... for high rates (how much are you charging?) I would expect an SEO to be
far more creative than that. Your post doesn't exactly sound like an attractive proposition.
I think posting other peoples stuff (unless they invite feedback) generally sucks.
I agree, and I wouldn't have gone out of my way to investigate it, however the website (albeit without the direct URL) was given as an example of their "quality" work.
It hardly shows you in a good light and doesn't help your "I charge large fees' for results" stance when they're outing the work as coming from a spam network. Sure it probably will provide results, but its certainly not work that deserves a large fee.
Good point, well made. It's exactly where I'm coming from.
And I think the bigger issue is that it scares people off posting anything worthwhile in the forum. Whats the point of posting anything to do with a ranking or an actual url if people are just going to pick holes in some dodgy backlinks out of spite? If I was reading this and thinking about posting something that involved showing a url, I'd have binned that idea now.
Unfortunately that's true as well. Picking holes certainly wasn't done out of spite in this instance as it's all in context and needed to be shown to demonstate your other point above. However, I can defintely see how holes would be picked by people in other cases regardless of context.
Would be great if worthwhile posts
could be made in the forum, but how worthwhile would it really be for someone to post up rankings based on a tonne of dodgy looking backlinks anyway? It doesn't take a genius to work out how to get them, and as you righly say it doesn't deserve a large fee for obtaining them either (all it really deserves is the cost of buying them).
If people are wanting advice when they post up websites which are not based on dodgy rankings and are all clean, then there will be nothing for even cynics to pick holes in. So anyone wanting genuine advice shouldn't really worry, and worthwhile posts can be made as a result.