I disagree. If I were looking to switch I’d probably just connect with the last bit of marketing I saw.
There are umpteen energy suppliers to choose from. All as bad as each other. So I might ask my mate down the pub who he uses.
I don’t have a clue about any of the branding or brand awareness they purport. So your asserting that it’s important isn’t always so. And isn’t for many considering the many conversations I’ve had over the years. Marketeers promote this idea and billions is spent on branding but most of it is wasted cash. I buy a type of biscuit because I like the taste. Not fussed who makes them.
I think we're talking about different aspects of branding. It's not always an immediate or direct strategy to get someone to buy, but rather a long-term, subtle process that creates familiarity over time. You might not think you're influenced by brand awareness, but even when your friend from the pub recommends something, their choice was likely shaped by brand recognition, which then influences you indirectly.
With the energy suppliers, the fact that you know some to at least label them as bad is part of brand awareness too. You may buy a biscuit for the taste, but that biscuit is on the supermarket shelf because the store has relationships with those brands, so even your choices are part of a larger chain influenced by branding.
The thing with big companies is that they continue to invest in brand awareness precisely because it works on this deeper, long-term level. Apple still advertises despite everyone knowing its name, and Nike still sponsors sports events even though we all know its logo. If brand awareness was a waste of money, these companies would go broke quicker than they are gaining users.
Just because you think you’re not personally influenced by branding doesn’t mean everyone around you isn’t. Many around you are affected by it, and for a fact, their opinions and decisions will influence you too, even if you don't realise it!
At the end we can agree to disagree, but overall it an interesting discussion and I would never cease to debate it (and I had many before, haha).