The "best" ecommerce product

Simon,
I'm not sure if you actually read the Google guidelines you linked to. I think you should.

"Duplicate content on a site is not grounds for action on that site unless it appears that the intent of the duplicate content is to be deceptive and manipulate search engine results. If your site suffers from duplicate content issues, and you don't follow the advice listed above, we do a good job of choosing a version of the content to show in our search results."

Nothing I have done on my testing site is either deceptive or manipulative, and in fact content is never as much as 85% similar, the generally accepted cutoff point.
"
"A good rule of thumb is whether you'd feel comfortable explaining what you've done to a website that competes with you. Another useful test is to ask, "Does this help my users? Would I do this if search engines didn't exist?"

Well yes. It helps my users as they can find me in another way, If the search engines didn't exist there would be no conversation, so that's a strange little thing they've said.

BTW, is "Doug" the same as Dawg? Confusing..

"He is blacklisted on Google for doing exactly what Doug is doing. He has spent the last two years trying to sort out the mess. Doug carry on at your peril. Perhaps Ray knows more than me, take your pick."

Fortunately I don't have to make a pick. There are several very knowledgeable people on this forum who proffer first rate advice without bluster, and here, and off forum the consensus of advice is that I am doing nothing that Google will penalize.

I hope that I'm wrong, but I do feel that because I had a go at your, ahem, interesting claims of national superiority,("No other solution on offer in the UK comes close to what we provide...it is most definitely the best" ), you are doing a wounded walrus impression, lashing out at me without thought.

It would be great to have someone of your experience and obvious dedication contributing here, and I suggest we all leave this now; start again another day.
 
Upvote 0
Dawg sells ten products on each site. The names of those products are identical as are the products you will receive if you purchase them. OK some of the text may vary, but it is clear to me that the only benefit is to gain more traffic from search engines. It does not benefit his customers.

We do use friendly URL's on new sites ( www.heat-outdoors.co.uk was launched yesterday) but it will take some time for all of our customers to change to the new system. It makes precious little difference to rankings on Google anyway.

As for the urls, yes I was aware that they are not blacklisted, I should have been clearer in my statement. My customer lost 90% of his free traffic as a result of having multiple sites selling identical products. It was as bad as being blacklisted. He still has some top listings 'leather sofas' is one example. I can assure you that it cost him a great deal of revenue.
 
Upvote 0
My customer lost 90% of his free traffic as a result of having multiple sites selling identical products.

Wrong, although your customer may have lost 90% of his traffic for duplicate content, nothing to do with products.

Ahem, a well known search engine beginning with G has multiple sites - some ending with .com others ending .co.uk, .fr, .au, .ca - no duplicate content penalties there.

Again, you will find this Forum as wealth of help and information and you can fill the extensive gaps in your e-commerce knowledge for free by asking questions - as many as you like.
 
Upvote 0
Simon
OK some of the text may vary, but it is clear to me that the only benefit is to gain more traffic from search engines

Thank Gawd you aren't in charge of Google, then 'eh?
You are talking the utmost drivel. Apart from the FAQS page (66%), the similar content % never goes above 23%, and on the product page it is 10%. They are on different hosts, at different domains, have no recognizable duplication that will be penalized: yet you, (who has to ask his 'techies' for backup, and who admits they have only scanned a source), you continue your preaching, based on your experience with a client who might have made a cobblers of it, or might have had that cobblers made for him.
I say Pah!
 
Upvote 0
Dawg

Google can see what you are doing which is why you have such poor listings. Why waste your time on all these sites when one carefully managed site would bring greater rewards?
I hadn't realised at first that you had created your own mini link farm. Not one of these sites offers any real new content. They are a waste of your time and money. Good luck, may you sell many biscuits and be happy.
End of.
Simon


www.bone-o-fido.co.uk
http://dogstreats.co.uk/
http://dawgmarkets.co.uk
http://idawg.co.uk
www.dog-treat.co.uk
www.dawganic.co.uk
www.dawgpix.co.uk
www.organic-dog.co.uk

www.calmdawg.com

P.S. Sorry if I missed any.
 
Upvote 0
Dawg

Google can see what you are doing which is why you have such poor listings.


Simon,

You are way out of your depth now and are frankly just coming across as a prize prat.

Finally, you have the offer to join us and let us help you fill in the massive gaps in your e-commerce knowledge.

You have a huge amount to learn, but we are here to help - you are not beyond saving (yet)
 
Upvote 0
Ray, get a life.

Out of my depth, you are joking of course. We can all learn from each other, but the gaps in my knowledge are far from massive. I never stop learning but it frustrates the hell out me when I know that I am right on this. Dawg can get on without my help as he can clearly do no wrong. Why should I care anyway? Prize Prat - no not me. I have learned nothing here today other than to keep my opinions to myself. Which is what I will do from now on.
Typically British - Support the under Dawg.
 
Upvote 0
Ray, get a life.

oh, hit me baby one more time
Out of my depth, you are joking of course.
Nope
but the gaps in my knowledge are far from massive.
You are the biggest prat, and the most self centred, I have witnessed here.

Of course, I could stomach that if you were correct in your aspersions - but you are constantly talking SH*T - so never mind.
 
Upvote 0

Latest Articles

Join UK Business Forums for free business advice