"The BBC is the best broadcasting company in the world"
We keep hearing this sort of statement, but we used to hear the same about the British bobby, the NHS, the Civil Service, the Mother of Parliaments and the rest.
And guess what? Bollox.
The BBC is a comfortable place to work for British middle class Oxbridge graduates who sneer at 'trade', (that's us BTW), who inhabit a comfy Islingtonia type headset, (estimates put the Guardian as paper of choice for 90% of the BBC newsrooms, that's balance huh?), and who live nice comfy lives away from the fray of competition, (which would be so demeaning, darling, and just not what creatives dooo).
Claims are made about the quality of the output. Technically OK but expensive compared to other suppliers it falls at a major hurdle: mass appeal. They chase after mass appeal, but just can't get it right.
For instance; the new Sherlock Holmes. Brilliant, funny, exciting, clever: great. Then we discover that there are only three, film length episodes. This is TV people, we want a series, like 13 weeks, an hour a hit. Sort of like the rest of the world does. But no: because the BBC can do as it pleases, without commercial considerations it makes bleedin' fillums instead.
On the commercial front the BBC breaks the copyright acts as a matter of course. That is: they ignore the law whilst taking our money. And now, in today's news, they are refusing to allow the National Audit Office to look at the books. If a private company acted like this they would be out of business very quickly, can you imagine: "The law doesn't apply to Megacorp PLC, and we decided we don't like audits either."
So to sum up: I don't believe the quality argument. But even were it true the BBC acts in a cavalier, law breaking fashion whilst extorting a licence fee (under threat of imprisonment), and is demonstrably partisan.
In answer to the OP: we pay for the BBC. It's a sort of welfare system for rich, clever people who can't be arsed to do a real job.
(Today's rant was not brought to you by Rupert the Murdoch)