Documenting Employee Behaviour Correctly and Fairly

jameZee

Free Member
Mar 26, 2017
34
4
After some recent behavioural issues (from one employee in particular), I have started documenting a recent stint of late attendance. Tardiness is a very tangible 'incident', straight-forward and easy to document, especially when communicating the negative impact it has on business performance.

What I'm really struggling with is; communicating fact driven explanations of seemingly subjective behaviour i.e. body language, tone of voice and impact on others.

Below is my list of examples (abridged and generalised for anonymity). On the face of it, you might think "geez, give this person a break!" but the below behaviours are becoming an unbearable pattern that must be addressed quickly, correctly and above all else, fairly.

Please be aware that plenty of groundwork and communication has gone into contracts, company handbook and job descriptions recently.

Employee behaviour notes:
  • During meeting X, reactions to requests: Rolls eyes, sighs and engages a negative tone of voice. Answers with phrases such as "Well, we can do that if you want". Creates an awkward and uncomfortable atmosphere due to tone of voice and body language (conveying a message of disinterest and resistance).
  • Uses silence, avoids eye contact, taps/drums fingers during meetings. When challenged on this behaviour, replies with; "Nothing, I'm fine".
  • Will avoid joining or starting a meeting with others by suddenly deciding to work on a completely unrelated task.
  • Avoids healthy and energetic discussions/debates that encourage the 'right thing to do for company and customer'. Usually avoids involvement or suggests solutions surrounding narrow self-interests.
  • Does less when asked for more: Sense of urgency decreases as workload or customer requirements increase. Other staff picking up slack (work that could easily be completed without assistance).
  • Fails to complete jobs X, Y and Z in a reasonable time-frame. Leaving one or two final, crucial steps incomplete for days, not hours. Not packaging the item for delivery. (Job X, Y and Z can be carried out/completed by a single person).
  • Procrastinates on removal of waste from the working environment (requires prompting after the deadline).
  • Failed to meet job deadline X. Will not ask for help or warn before it's too late to salvage.
  • Cites unrealistic completion times leading to an unreliable production/delivery times
  • Frequently forgets to complete elements of jobs and avoids writing lists (when requested as a solution to solve forgetfulness).
  • Failure to work simultaneously (i.e. tidy up whilst a machine is left running safely) to help avoid backlogs (linear approach).
On the face of it, one might argue; most of these examples all subjective and not substantial enough behaviour to be considered a problem. But to me and others, it's like trying to put squares of tissue on 1,000 paper-cuts.

The other tricky issue is addressing this behaviour. When confronting or challenging such issues, the employee has a plausible explanation (excuse) to justify behaviour and uses these strategies across most situations.

If I am to continue documenting and taking an approach of progressive discipline, my questions are; 1. Are these notes up to required standards? And; 2. How can would you communicate these issues back to the employee fairly but effectively to encourage improvement?

Thanks for reading.
 

Lucan Unlordly

Free Member
Feb 24, 2009
3,985
996
I'm bemused?

Apart from the first two most of the other points you raise are identifiable acts which should be easy to take action against.

'Will avoid joining a meeting'. There's a meeting, get your backside in here, now or face disciplinary action.

'Procrastinates on removal of waste' There's a deadline. Meet it or face disciplinary action...

'Frequently forgets to complete elements of jobs and writing lists to avoid forgetfulness.' Here's a list for you , 10am Monday morning in HR.
 
Upvote 0

Mr D

Free Member
Feb 12, 2017
28,915
3,627
Stirling
Similar list of issues can be found in some people with depression.

Part of the problem is - people do not always even acknowledge when they have depression. And can be undiagnosed for years, decades even.

And part of the problem is someone who does not want to be there simply because they would rather be elsewhere will come across the same way.
Would not suggest trying to figure out if its mental health issue just from a forum post but to me it sounds very much like depression.
 
Upvote 0

Newchodge

Moderator
  • Business Listing
    Nov 8, 2012
    22,689
    8
    8,005
    Newcastle
    What is wrong with inviting them to a meeting to discuss a number of issues relating to their attitude at work and going through that list. Do not accept any excuse. Listen to what they have to say about each individual issue and pull it all together and say that while a single issue on a single occasion may be excusable, the extent of issues needs addressing and further occurrences will be dealt with through the disciplinary process.

    Unless they have been with you less than 2 years, in which case I would just tell them it is ntot working out, here is your notice pay, holiday pay and P45.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: obscure
    Upvote 0

    obscure

    Free Member
    Jan 18, 2008
    3,370
    879
    The world
    Listen to what they have to say about each individual issue and pull it all together and say that while a single issue on a single occasion may be excusable, the extent of issues needs addressing and further occurrences will be dealt with through the disciplinary process.
    ^^ This.

    One or two issue/excuses would be acceptable but when there are many more than any other staff member the excuses cease to be credible.
     
    Upvote 0

    Latest Articles

    Join UK Business Forums for free business advice