Byretorial - Thanks Ken!

If you run an online shop, you need to read this. Actually, if you even buy stuff online, you need to read this. I was talking to the elderly owner called Ken of a medium-sized online shop and wondered at his low prices. He was charging less than the wholesale price and included next-day delivery in that price. The items he sold are chainsaws and other forestry and gardening tools that very strictly only go out to bricks-n-mortar shops and have an average retail price of around £750.

We got chatting and I knew how difficult it was for our local dealer to get these items and how hard it was to match any online prices. Our local dealership, despite having a turnover of over £40m, just cannot match this guy's online prices. They just don't buy enough stuff and they would be better off buying online than buying from the manufacturer! So I had to ask my new friend how he manages to sell at such low prices - and after some umming and erring, he told me - and I'll tell you in a minute.

Inflation is up. Interest rates are heading north, but by no means can they go anywhere near any figure that could tame true inflation. And as it takes about two years for newly printed money to enter the real economy, all that QE from the past two years will only start to erode your bottom line this year.

True GDP as measured by the amount of goods and services created (i.e. NOT nominal GDP as measured in pounds) has fallen since 2019. Homeless figures are up everywhere. True unemployment (as measured by the percentage of people not in full-time employment) is up and rising. An energy price shock is coming down the line and is unstoppable. House prices are off to the races.

But it is all that loose money that is still washing down the mountainside that is scary! It has to go somewhere - and that somewhere may be in more stockmarket craziness.

When the fund managers see that none of the central banks are able to tame inflation without bankrupting their governments and that reserve rates will remain well below inflation levels - even well below the bogus figures put out by government departments like the ONS - those fund managers may start to say to themselves "Jeez, the Fed, the BoE and the ECB are toothless, clawless and clueless tigers. Let's load up with cheap money and have another share buying binge before the bubble bursts!"

We all know that PE ratios are too high and the world's stock markets are in a bubble as prices are too high for the underlying fundamentals of the companies involved. We also know that some of the big tech companies more or less doubled in value since the outbreak of C19 madness.

I'm not saying that is what will happen - I'm just saying that is what MAY happen when the markets realise that the only central bank that is going to fight inflation is in Moscow. All other central banks have negative interest rates in real terms - i.e. nominally positive but far less than inflation. And don't forget that true inflation is always about double the official figures for CPI because the basket of goods and services used to measure inflation is constantly being changed.

All that QE currency has to go somewhere and the market may melt-up before it melts down!

There is an old saying in economics - the cure for high prices is high prices. In other words, the market regulates itself. The cure for high share prices is a market correction. You may call it a bubble bursting or just a price deflation. You can call it whatever you like, but what goes up, must come down. The cure for Alphabet Inc. at $3,000 is Alphabet Inc. at $1,000.

The cure for high energy prices is high energy prices - and not price controls. But our schoolboy chancellor will have noted the support from former chief whip Mark Harper, (who praised his "realism and honesty"), and Blue Collar Conservatives founder Esther McVey (who said she was "grateful we have a chancellor who is in touch", with families struggling on low incomes). Sunak is within touching distance of becoming Prime Minister. One Tory MP close to the 1922 Committee believes they are "within single digits" of the 54 threshold.

Johnson himself rejected calls to resign over 'partygate', telling The Sun that he will seek re-election in 2024, as he strives to 'level up' the country with The Govenator Plan. Tories are wondering if the prospect that Johnson could be out of office soon is the reason why Michael Ashcroft is publishing his biography of Carrie Johnson on March 22, instead of just before the Conservative Party conference. After all, few people will want to buy a biography about the wife of a former prime minister. The cure for Johnson's tomfoolery is even more of Johnson's tomfoolery.

And the cure for my local dealership wanting £1,600 inc. VAT for a chainsaw is an online shop selling me one for £1,125. If we strip out the VAT, that is £22.50 under wholesale list price. Along with many manufacturers, the manufacturer of my choice of chainsaw has realised that online box shifters with sophisticated websites sporting in-depth video reviews of everything they sell and even comparing brands are more important to their bottom line than local specialised dealerships giving pointless advice that is just thinly disguised up-selling.

So what is different about this brave new world of retail? With his last order, elderly Ken bought one thousand chainsaws.

Thanks Ken!
 

Newchodge

Moderator
  • Business Listing
    Nov 8, 2012
    22,821
    8
    8,052
    Newcastle
    In other words, the economy is self-correcting. We more Kens and less government and central bank intervention.
    The economy. You use that phrase as if you are referrig to a single, unchanging entity. That's your first, and probably fatal, mistake.
     
    Upvote 0
    QE is so that lazy governments can look magnanimous by throwing money around without appearing to raise taxes - except that QE leads to inflation and inflation is a tax on the poor and the middle classes.

    The economy. You use that phrase as if you are referrig to a single, unchanging entity.
    At what point have I ever made that claim - only a fool would do so!
     
    • Like
    Reactions: simon field
    Upvote 0
    He is keeping prices down by changing the way he (and the manufacturer) is doing business.

    My old chainsaw cost about £200 some 30 years ago (and is still going strong). I bought it at the local dealership and paid the list price. The equivalent model today has a list price of £800 and is rebated down to £600 online. That is for a 50cc, 3kW Stihl. The one I bought was an 80cc, 8kW 500i.

    In the same vein, Aldi and Lidl have forced the prices down at the other supermarkets.

    Whether you are the local chainsaw dealership, a supermarket or the government, you cannot go on milking the public or finding new taxes for companies indefinitely. People and businesses find new ways of doing things that avoid paying more.

    If government spending goes above 35% of GDP, people spend less and pay less tax and the Luffer curve sets in. At least it does so in the medium term as companies relocate and people do not declare all their income and money starts to leave the country.

    US states are discovering this to their cost. Poor people are staying in the high-tax states because that is where they get the highest benefits. Wealthier people are moving from places like NY and California to low-tax Florida and many really rich people are either moving their assets off-shore or moving away altogether to places like zero-tax Puerto Rico.
     
    Upvote 0
    QE causes inflation and inflation causes changes in the marketplace. Old structures, such as fixed wholesale prices and main dealerships, area protection and even exclusive supply to B&M shops get swept away as new realities force everybody to rethink the very fundamentals of their markets.

    My new friend Ken may have bought 1,000 chainsaws as a first-order and is now shifting them by the pallet load, but his operation is tiny (a converted small petrol station in the countryside) compared to our local dealer who has a chain of large shops turning over £40m p.a. but sells thousands of items.

    I'm not saying this change is good or bad. I'm just saying that it is happening.
     
    Upvote 0

    UKSBD

    Moderator
  • Dec 30, 2005
    13,057
    1
    2,847
    I'm not saying this change is good or bad. I'm just saying that it is happening.

    It creates a whole new sector

    An example

    Mobility scooters - they would cost £1,000 from *Reputable Dealer ltd*

    Someone wants to physically see it, built in to the price.
    Someone wants a demonstration, built in to the price.
    Someone requires instructions on how to use it, built into the price.
    Someone wants, slight adjustments, built in to the price.
    Someone wants adjustments after a few months, built in to the price

    *Dropship but do nothing else ltd* starts selling the exact same model online for £600

    All the punter sees is the £400 difference and thinks *Reputable Dealer ltd* is ripping him off.

    Worse still, the punter goes to *Reputable Dealer ltd* to see it, have a demonstration, get instructions, but then goes and buys from *Dropship but do nothing else ltd*

    If they need any adjustments they are stuffed, if they need alterations they are stuffed, if it breaks down they are stuffed.

    If *Reputable Dealer ltd* are sensible they then provide an adjustment service, alteration service, maintenance service, warrant package but charge more for this than they would have if it was part of the initial deal.
     
    Upvote 0
    And yet, a smart buyer could have bought 1000 chainsaws without QE, and got the discount, and made loads of money.
    Nope. They used to not give those generous discounts. You might have got 10% or 20%, but not so that you could sell below list-wholesale and provide next-day delivery.

    We saw it happen with white goods, then TVs and hifi stuff and we have been seeing it happen with cameras. Even stuff like tractors (and I don't mean just cheap Chinese brands either, but the up-market name brands) are being discounted.

    It should not take too long before some car manufacturers realise that with marginal production costs just one-fifth (or less) of retail, they need to start rethinking their distribution and marketing arrangements.

    To some extent, they already are in some markets such as Australia, but they are making a pig's ear of dealing with disgruntled car dealerships who are banding together to prevent a market restructure with legal action - for obvious reasons!
    Has drop shipping improved business for repair service providers?

    Probably a good business to get in to - Provide the after care service a reputable dealer would provide but that drop shippers don't.
    I think that exists already - after all, who but a naive fool goes to the local dealership for car service and repairs? Good indi repair shops are in every town and every area has its own 'Stig-with-a-Spanner' workshop!
     
    Upvote 0

    japancool

    Free Member
  • Jul 11, 2013
    9,740
    1
    3,449
    Leeds
    japan-cool.uk
    Nope. They used to not give those generous discounts. You might have got 10% or 20%, but not so that you could sell below list-wholesale and provide next-day delivery.

    We saw it happen with white goods, then TVs and hifi stuff and we have been seeing it happen with cameras. Even stuff like tractors (and I don't mean just cheap Chinese brands either, but the up-market name brands) are being discounted.

    All that would have happened with or without QE.
     
    • Like
    Reactions: MBE2017
    Upvote 0

    Latest Articles

    Join UK Business Forums for free business advice