I woke up at 1:30 AM last night, and for some reason the logical thing to do seemed to be to read this whole thread.
At the start I was shocked at how weak the punishments were.
And how little checking was done.
6 year directorship disqualification for 50K - many people would knowingly go for that even if it was a dead cert. Get your wife to direct the company etc, run a sole trader, go back to work. Not much hinderance for the money.
Only on the last few pages there have been some sentences, I think without exception the sentence was suspended.
Brief thoughts:
Obviously no checks were being done - they should have been checking companies house at least, and supporting evidence of turn over should have been needed.
The Banks should not get taxpayer protection for the cases where the fraud was possible to easily check as above.
The max loan should have been the corporation tax paid on the most recent ct600 (in the last x years) limited to 50K. This is similar to the 1/4th of recent turn over figure, but easier to check against data already submit
These low hanging fruit should be the cases that they are absolutely nailing people for. Sentences, community service on TOP of repayment and all the stress + hassle of the process.
It will be interesting to see how much the figures have changed on repayments / default etc in the 2024 March update.
The period between getting the loan and sending to your bank account seems to figure in the prosecutions. This just makes it blatant. Smarter people dripping it here and there that are closing / dwindling companies out need forensic investigating.
The comedian's case of using the money to live does have some legs, his humour is the companies only asset, so he needs to exist. The question is, was any rainy day saving done, were there assets that could have been used, IE was it necessary. If faced with having this decided by a court we might find repayments flying back in.
Its 50K a time, its worth spending the country £ effort to recover. I don't understand why they did not give more to the investigations team as presumably it is a profit center.
From this
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/covid-19-loan-guarantee-schemes-repayment-data/covid-19-loan-guarantee-schemes-performance-data-as-at-31-march-2023
~£77B drawn - or a £1180 contribution from every man woman and child.
around £51B is on target to be repaid
this leaves about £230 currently looking dicey / defaulted / required / will require settlement from gov that every person will contribute to. Disgusting and the perpetrators need to be held to account, literally.
I'm sure we've all heard stories. I'd hoped that people would not get away with it, or with just a disqualification from holding directorship.